Jim Murray’s reviews
Here you will find all our bottlings, that have been rated by Jim Murray.
| 0–50.5 51–64.5 65–69.5 70–74.5 75–79.5 |
Nothing short of absolutely diabolical Nasty and well worth avoiding Very unimpressive indeed Usually drinkable but don’t expect the earth to move Average and usually pleasant though sometimes flawed |
80–84.5 85–89.5 90–93.5 94–97.5 98–100 |
Good whisky worth trying Very good to excellent whiskies definitely worth buying Brilliant Superstar whiskies that give us all a reason to live Better than anything I’ve ever tasted! |
|
2016 edition |
|
2017 edition |
||
|
Bowmore 16Y – 58.6% SOLD OUT! Distilled: 25.09.1998 92.5 point |
 |
Bladnoch 9Y – 61.3% SOLD OUT! Distilled: 17.03.2007 88.5 point |
 |
|
|
Glen Ord 15Y – 50.7% SOLD OUT! Distilled: 1997 93.5 point |
 |
Linkwood 21Y – 47.5% SOLD OUT! Distilled: 05.06.1995 93.0 point |
 |
|
|
2018 edition |
|
2019 edition |
||
|
Ledaig 15Y – 57% SOLD OUT! Distilled: September 2000 89.5 point |
 |
Fettercairn 21Y – 63.5% Distilled: 27.09.1996 85.5 point |
 |
|
|
Bruichladdich 14Y – 57.2% SOLD OUT! Distilled: November 2001 92.0 point |
 |
Glen Grant 22Y – 51.9% Distilled: 27.07.1995 95.0 point |
 |
|
|
Dumbarton 30Y – 57.2% Distilled: 18.03.1987 89.5 point |
 |
Glentauchers 19Y – 53.3% SOLD OUT! Distilled: 27.09.1996 85.5 point |
 |
|
|
Macduff 14Y – 60.3% Refill Sherry 88.5 point |
 |
|||
|
Ledaig 10Y – 55.8% SOLD OUT! PX Oloroso Finish 71.5 point |
 |
|||
|
Ledaig 20Y – 60.7% SOLD OUT! Refill Sherry 86.5 point |
 |
|||
|
Ben Nevis 21Y – 51.1% SOLD OUT! Refill Sherry 95.5 point |
 |
|||
|
2020 edition |
2021 edition |
|||
|
Auchroisk 7Y – 59.3% SOLD OUT! 1st Fill Oloroso 91.5 point |
 |
Bruichladdich 15Y – 62.3% SOLD OUT! 1st Fill Sherry 94 point |
 |
|
|
Caol Ila 7Y – 60% 1st fill Entre Deux Mers 80.5 point |
 |
Girvan 13Y – 61.2% Distilled: 11.07.2006 86,5 point |
 |
|
|
Treasure of Islay 10Y – 58.4% (Caol Ila) 95.5 point |
 |
Glenallachie 11Y – 62.3% SOLD OUT! Refill Sherry 88 point |
 |
|
|
Westport 11Y – 56.2% (Glenmorangie) 86.0 point |
 |
Linkwood 10Y – 59.4% Distilled: 18.11.2008 91 point |
 |
|
|
Orkney 12Y – 62.4% SOLD OUT! (Highland Park) 94.5 point |
 |
Linkwood 11Y – 57.8% SOLD OUT! 1st Fill Oloroso Finish 88,5 point |
 |
|
|
Orkney 14Y – 55.4% SOLD OUT! (Highland Park) 95.5 point |
 |
Macduff 13Y – 54.2% Distilled: 27.11.2006 92 point |
 |
|
|
Orkney 15Y – 58.6% (Highland Park) 91.5 point |
 |
MacRothes 25Y – 56.6% 1st Fill Sherry 89,5 point |
 |
|
|
Tomatin 10Y – 60.2% Distilled: 02.04.2009 91.0 point |
 |
Tomatin 10Y – 59.9% 2nd Fill Sherry Finish 94,5 point |
 |
|
|
Secret Speyside 26Y – 51.3% SOLD OUT! (UnNamed Macallan) 86.5 point |
 |
Dalmore 11Y – 55.2% SOLD OUT! 1st Fill Oloroso Finish 94 point |
 |
|
|
Balmenach 7Y – 55.4% 1st Fill PX Finish 90 point |
 |
|||
|
Balmenach 7Y – 52.8% 1st Fill PX Finish 84,5 point |
 |
|||